The report displays exceptional research in both its scope and skills of enquiry 

The report provides a thoroughly convincing and comprehensive account of how the person of commitment made a positive difference to the world and how this was influenced by his/her personal values/religious belief/worldview 

There is evidence of insightful personal reflection on the learning and awareness of what it means for the student  

The report displays very good research in both its scope and skills of enquiry 

The report provides a convincing and comprehensive account of how the person of commitment made a positive difference to the world and how this was influenced by his/her personal values/religious belief/worldview 

There is good evidence of personal reflection on the learning and what it means for the student  

The report displays good research in both its scope and skills of enquiry  

The report provides a reasonably clear and coherent account of how the person of commitment made a positive difference to the world and how this was influenced by his/her personal values/religious belief/worldview 

There is some evidence of personal reflection on the learning and what it means for the student, albeit rather limited.  

The report displays limited research in both its scope and skills of enquiry 

The report provides a very basic account of how the person of commitment made a positive difference to the world but little evidence of how this was influenced by their chosen person’s values/religious belief/worldview  

There is little or no evidence of personal reflection on the learning and what it means for the student.