Section J

RELIGION AND SCIENCE

Aims

  1. To develop an awareness of the changing nature and methods ofthe scientific and theological enterprises.
  2. To examine some key moments in the history of the relationshipbetween religion and science.
  3. To examine some of the issues and debates concerning thecontemporary relationship between religion and science.
  4. To explore the ethical implications of scientific progress.

Part one

THE SCIENTIFIC AND THEOLOGICAL ENTERPRISES

Objectives

Students should be able to

KnowledgeUnderstandingSkillsAttitudes
  • understand the question, common and particular, to the theological and scientific enterprises
  • be aware of the importance of the community context for science and technology.
  • have an understanding of the connections between the scientific and theological enterprises, particularly in contemporary science and theology.
  • differentiate between the scientific and theological enterprises.

This section should contributeto the development of

  • appreciation of the value of human questioning from a scientific and theological point of view.
   
1.1 Questioningincontext
  • the human need to question
  • questions of nature, relationship, meaning, purpose, and origin
  • questions common to science and religion
  • God of the gaps'
  • two other images of God and their implications for science.

As a result of studying this section, students should be able to

  • explain the human drive to question and to ask why
  • compile and present a 'list' of ultimate questions
  • give examples of the questions common to religion and science
  • demonstrate an understanding of 'God of the gaps' and of science's critique of this view
  • present two alternative images of God and their use in the debate between science and religion.
1.2 Community
  • the importance of community for the theological and scientific enterprises
  • objective or subjective investigation
  • scientific method and theories of interpretation
  • theology and theories of interpretation.

As a result of studying this section, students should be able to

  • define community and outline reasons for its importance in theology and science
  • define 'objective' and 'subjective' investigation, and discuss the merits of each
  • describe the elements of scientific method and interpretation
  • outline the methods of interpretation available to theology.

Part two

THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN RELIGION AND SCIENCE

Objectives

Students should be able to

KnowledgeUnderstandingSkillsAttitudes
  • be familiar with key moments in the relationship between science and theology from the Renaissance to the present day
  • be able to identify possible future points of conflict and communication for science and theology.
  • be aware of the lack of understanding of these connections in the past and the consequent tensions between science and theology
  • have an awareness of the limits and possibilities of the dialogue between religion and science
  • be aware of the lack of understanding of these connections in the past and the consequent tensions between science and theology.
  • engage critically in current debates between religion and science
  • identify ethical implications of scientific progress.

This section should contribute to the development of

  • appreciation of the limitations of scientific and religious fundamentalism
  • openness to the insights of science and religion in current debates.
TopicDescription of contentOutcomes
2.1 Science and religion go their separate ways
  • Galileo and his context
    • the methods and theories of Galileo
    • the reaction from the secular and religious world
  • the beginnings of modern science
  • the reaction of religions.

As a result of studying this section, students should be able to

  • present a portrait of the world from which Galileo's ideas emerged
  • describe the methods Galileo used
  • present an summary of Galileo's main findings and ideas
  • explain the various sources of modern science
  • show the various reactions of religions to the rise of science.
2.2 Science versus religion
  • Descartes and his influence
    • the disappearance of God
    • the significance of the cogito
  • Newton and the mathematical paradigm
  • science and religion in the enlightenment.

As a result of studying this section, students should be able to

  • outline Descartes's theory and explain its importance for science and religion
  • explain the importance of Newton's discoveries in mathematics for the relationship between science and religion
  • describe one major development in science and one major development in religion at the time of the enlightenment.
2.3 Science and religion in tension
  • Charles Darwin and his context
  • Darwin and evolution
    • Darwin's investigations
    • the development of a theory of evolution
  • the response of religions with particular reference to one of the following: Buddhism Christianity, Hinduism, Islam, or Judaism.

As a result of studying this section, students should be able to

  • explain the influences on Darwin's thought
  • outline Darwin's theory of evolution, and highlight the major areas of conflict with religion
  • describe the reaction of one major world religion to Darwin's theory at the time of its development.
2.4 Science and religion in dialogue
  • the understanding of creation in either the Buddhist Christian, Hindu, Islamic or Jewish tradition
  • a contrasting understanding of creation from another religious tradition
  • the ecological crisis
  • the main features of the current crisis
    • the origins of the crisis
    • attitudes to the crisis from the perspectives of theology and science.

As a result of studying this section, students should be able to

  • outline the understanding of creation in one of either
    • Buddhism
    • Christianity
    • Hinduism
    • Islam
    • Judaism
  • contrast two understandings of creation from two different religious traditions
  • outline the contemporary ecological crisis
  • present a theologian's perspective on the crisis
  • present a scientist's perspective on the crisis.

Part three

(Students study either part three or part four)

CURRENT ISSUES FOR RELIGION AND SCIENCE: ORIGINS

Objectives

Students should be able to

KnowledgeUnderstandingSkillsAttitudes
  • identify possible future points of conflict and communication for science and theology.
  • have an understanding of the connections between the scientific and theological enterprises, particularly in contemporary science and theology
  • have an awareness of the limits and possibilities of the dialogue between religion and science
  • have an understanding of the ethical implications of scientific progress
  • have an understanding of theological perspectives on current developments in physics or biology.
  • -differentiate between the scientific and theological enterprises
  • engage critically in current debates between religion and science
  • identify ethical implications of scientific progress.

This section should contribute to the development of

  • awareness of the limitations of scientific and religious fundamentalism
  • openness to the insights of science and religion in current debates
  • critical evaluation of scientific and technological progress.
TopicDescription of contentOutcomes
3.1 The debate about origins
  • why bother about origins?
  • an overview of current debate on origins
  • ancient and contemporary cosmologies
    • two ancient contrasting cosmologies
    • two contemporary contrasting cosmologies.

As a result of studying this section, students should be able to

  • explain the importance of reflecting on and studying origins
  • give a summary of the main features of current debate on origins
  • explain the term "cosmology"
  • present two contemporary and two ancient cosmologies and identify similarities and differences.
3.2 The new physics and religion - emerging questions
  • Heisenberg's uncertainty principle and the development of quantum theory
  • science and the realm of chance, probability, and chaos
  • theological perspectives on these developments.

As a result of studying this section, students should be able to

  • explain the Heisenberg uncertainty principle and its importance for science today
  • outline two of the key ideas associated with 'new physics' and the importance of these for theological reflection.

Part four

(Students study either part three or part four)

CURRENT ISSUES FOR RELIGION AND SCIENCE: LIFE AND DEATH

Objectives

Students should be able to

KnowledgeUnderstandingSkillsAttitudes
- identify possible future points of conflict and communication for science and theology.
  • have an understanding of the connections between the scientific and theological enterprises, particularly in contemporary science and theology
  • have an awareness of the limits and possibilities of the dialogue between religion and science
  • have an understanding of the ethical implications of scientific progress
  • have an understanding of the theological perspectives on current developments in genetics.
  • differentiate between the scientific and theological enterprises
  • engage critically in current debates between religion and science
  • identify ethical implications of scientific progress.

This section should contribute to the development of

  • awareness of scientific and religious fundamentalism
  • openness to the insights of science and religion in current debates
  • critical evaluation of scientific and technological progress.
TopicDescription of contentOutcomeS
4.1 The life questions
  • Scientific descriptions of the beginnings of life and the moment of death
  • religious descriptions of the beginnings of life and the moment of death.

As a result of studying this section, students should be able to

  • present scientific and religious accounts of the beginning and ending of life and indicate areas where science and religion share the same concerns.
4.2 The genetics debate
  • the religious and scientific perspectives in relation to two of the following:
    • cloning
    • genetically-modified life
    • artificially created life
    • the prolonging of life
    • the ending of life.

As a result of studying this section, students should be able to

  • outline the ethical issues that arise in science and religion in two of the following
    • cloning
    • genetically-modified life
    • artificially created life
    • the prolonging of life
    • the ending of life.
 
NCCA, 24 Merrion Square, Dublin 2, Telephone: +353 1 661 7177, Fax: +353 1 661 7180, E-mail: info@ncca.ie